"Weingarten rights" derive from a 1975 Supreme Court
case, NLRB v. J. Weingarten, Inc. Essentially, they are the right to
request assistance from union representatives during investigatory
interviews, so that a steward may prevent management from coercing an
employee into confessions of misconduct (either through threatening
behavior, or simply through skilled interrogation techniques). The
union steward can:
- serve as a witness to the actual content of the
investigation;
- object to intimidating tactics or confusing
questions;
- help an employee avoid making "fatal admissions;"
- advise an employee, when appropriate, against
denying everything, and thereby giving the appearance of guilt or
dishonesty;
- counsel an employee against losing her/his
temper;
- discourage an employee from informing on others;
- raise extenuating factors.
Weingarten rights apply only in investigatory
interviews -- that is, when management questions an employee to obtain
information; and the employee has a reasonable belief that discipline
(or other negative consequences) may result. If an employee is called
in to a supervisor's office merely to be informed of a disciplinary
decision, the courts have found that this is not an investigatory
meeting. The decision to discipline the employee has already been
made. However, if the supervisor asks additional questions about the
employee's conduct, the meeting becomes an investigatory interview.