The urge to crawl inside my TV
WORLD, 05-01-1995
I tested positive in 1992. Even living in San Francisco, I had never met another woman with HIV. I felt terribly
alone.
Not long after that, the 8th International Conference on AIDS was held in Amsterdam. I watched the news
vigilantly. There was no cure, but one night I caught a news brief on TV. Fifty women from all over the world
took the stage and proclaimed that they were women living with--not dying from--HIV. They had just formed a
network called the International Community of Women Living with HIV/AIDS (" ICW"). As I stared at each face, I
felt an overwhelming urge to crawl inside the TV set and join them. Reportback from South Africa
In March, I travelled to Cape Town South Africa to participate in the Third International Pre-Conference for
Women Living with HIV/AIDS (sponsored by the ICW) and the 7th International Conference for People Living with
HIV/AIDS co-hosted by the Global Network of People Living with HIV/AIDS (GNP+). Here are excerpts from my
report, with thanks to the many individuals who contributed their notes.
Third International Conference for Women with HIV/AIDS
On March 4th, 1995, over 150 HIV+ women from over 40 countries gathered in Cape Town, South Africa, for the
3rd International Conference for Women Living with HIV and AIDS. The majority of the women (52%) came from
South Africa and other African countries. The rest came from Europe (20%), North America (10%), Latin
America and the Caribbean (10%) and Asia Pacific (8%).
Over the next two days, the ICW held plenary sessions, a business meeting, regional meetings, elections, and a
number of issue-specific workshops where women were able to share experience useful information, learn
from one another and realize that they are not alone. As one woman expressed:
"It gives me a good feeling to know that no matter how bad or hard the struggle gets, there is always a sister
somewhere out there sending out positive energy to you, praying that you will make it." Positive women speak
out
Dr. Nkosazana Zuma, South Africa's Minister of Health, gave the opening speech, welcoming us all to South
Africa. She stated that with support of President Nelson Mandela she is working to see that HIV be addressed
by all sectors of government. Then a panel of HIV+ women spoke about their regions.
A 22 year old lesbian from South Africa tested positive at the age of 17. She had experienced horrific isolation
and commented, "I had to lose a lot before I could be who I am." Today she has made the fight against HIV and
AIDS a huge part of her purpose in living.
A single woman in her early thirties from the Caribbean reported that there is now a growing network of HIV+
women in Latin America and the Carribean.
A married mother from Australia pointed out that while Asia now has the fastest growing rate of infection in the
world, there were only a handful of women from the Asia/Pacific region present at the pre- conference.
Outreach in her region is very difficult due to the lack of information and the incredible stigma attached to the
disease.
A woman from Singapore is the only woman who has ever gone public in her area. She took advantage of the
chance to network saying, "I may be alone in Singapore, but I'm not alone here."
A woman from Germany said ICW members in her region are doing a scan of Italy, France, Spain, Portugal and
Ireland to assess the needs of women there. Despite the perceived plethora of information, access to services
in Europe is still limited for most HIV+ women.
A woman from the United States then spoke about women's AIDS projects going on in the USA and Canada,
including a new regional ICW group forming in Canada, and the WORLD newsletter which works closely with the
ICW to disseminate information worldwide.
Finally, a woman from Malawi shared that she and other African women were feeling proud and strong to have
the conference in Africa with widespread participation by African women. She reported that in Africa the ICW
women have been coming out and mobilizing. African women speak out
On the second day of the conference, a panel of African women spoke. A woman from Tanzania opened this
plenary session discussing the role of women in African society, where she said women are often treated as
second class citizens. She described polygamy as the norm, said that violence against women is common, and
that women are taught early on to never refuse sex from their husbands.
A woman from the Ivory Coast said that HIV+ women in Africa suffer discrimination on all levels: health,
education, and employment. Many women spoke of the lack of resources, and of socio-economic dependence
on men. Women are denied equal access to education which perpetuates the inequality. When women can not
get good jobs, they feel powerless and may be forced into prostitution to survive. When a woman's husband
dies, inheritance laws often deprive her of his property.
In Zimbabwe we were told women are afraid to seek treatment for any sexually transmitted disease (STD)
because they are often questioned and judged about how they acquired the disease. A woman rarely has the
power to refuse sex or negotiate condom use with her husband. Greater outreach to rural areas is also greatly
needed.
A woman from Botswana said women lack access to information because it is usually in English (which many
African women do not read or speak).
A Kenyan woman spoke about pregnancy in African society where motherhood is glorified, and makes women
recognized by society. Yet while women are praised for giving birth, they are given no rights of their own. When
men move to urban areas, women inherit the task of caring for the children alone. Nevertheless, women who
can't have children face a very difficult situation.
Finally, a woman from Botswana spoke about children who suffer stigmatization by friends when a parent has
HIV. When parents become ill, older children often end up caring for the parents and the younger children. We
must care for orphans and educate all children so that they can avoid getting HIV.
South African Conference Workshops
During the two day conference, women participated in a series of workshops:
Sexual abuse/harassment/violence
At least three women disclosed that they had been directly infected during a rape. Others said that the low
self-esteem they experienced as a result of sexual abuse had led them to engage in high risk behaviors. Some
said they were afraid to ask men to use condoms.
Some HIV+ women stay in abusive relationships because they are afraid no one else will love them. Others stay
because and abusive partner threatens to disclose her status if she leaves. One woman's husband slept with a
gun under his pillow to threaten her. Economic dependence is another reason women stay in abusive
relationships.
Women are frustrated that laws don't protect them or their children from violence. Some are teaching their boy
children to respect women. Other strategies include reassuring women that they are not to blame for the
violence of others. Overcoming Isolation
Women discussed the tendency to self-isolated due to fear of rejection by friends or family members. A woman
from Kenya shared that when she tested positive, her partner abandoned her seven months pregnant, with only
the kicking of her baby to keep her company. An African woman residing in Scandinavia fears being deported. A
woman from Zimbabwe, took her sick child to the hospital at 3 p.m. only to be refused services because she had
AIDS. The baby died in her arms 32 hours later.
Job discrimination was another theme. A woman in England had lost her job after it was deemed inappropriate
for her to do home care in 1987. A Malaysian woman is afraid to disclose to her current employer. A South
African woman was afraid to tell her husband or co-workers because the people around her believe AIDS is "a
white man's disease." Pregnancy
Women from poor countries expressed frustration that they don't have access to information or treatments
available in more developed countries. In Africa, for example, women have little or no access to AZT, pre- natal
vitamins, basic health care, or adequate nutrition, despite a recent study from Malawi that shows a connection
between malnutrition and perinatal transmission of HIV.
While it is recommended that HIV+ women not breast feed, in some countries it may be the only source of
nutrition for a child. Most African women don't have access to formula and even if they do, they can't always be
sure that the water they mix it with is safe for consumption. Health Issues
Many health concerns were identified by the women: Treatment by health providers:
lack of respect and sensitivity doctors giving no/poor information
about treatments/symptoms not getting to ask question
doctors not taking symptoms seriously lack of training re HIV+ women
being labeled a "difficult" patient being treated medically as if women are like men breasts
Lack of Services: no access to pap smears during regular check ups
no access to appropriate health care in rural areas Gynecological problems:
pre-menstrual syndrome irregular/painful/missing periods
other STDs (chlamydia, herpes...) reproductive problems
ovarian cancer/ovarian cysts vaginal thrust/yeast infections pregnancy and infertility
contraceptives/side effects poor memory/illness with periods
Additional Concerns: fevers, headaches, dry mouth skin problems breast cancer
body image mental/spiritual health
One woman's doctor had recommended she get a mastectomy. (He presumed she would not be having children,
so she didn't need her breast.) Several women expressed the need for regular gynecological care as preventive
medicine, before problems arise.
While most women only see a western doctor for treatment, nearly every woman uses both western and
traditional treatments for her only well being, including herbs, aroma therapy, massage and so on. Many said the
western treatments were too toxic so they preferred the more natural remedies. Skin problems were another
frequent concern.
Women discussed the need to "shop around" for health care to find a doctor that will work with you, not dictate
to you. Women from the U.S. and Africa alike commented that once some providers know you're HIV+ they don't
put as much effort into treating symptoms, as if they feel you're going to die anyway, so why bother.
Some noted that absence of women from clinical trials, while others raised concerns about trials that exploit
women in poor countries with little access to care.
Suggestions for improving our health
We need our doctors to be our partners, not our saviors We need preventative care.
Study relation between HIV and menstrual irregularities
Prepare a list of question to discuss with your doctor. Take a friend.
Women need to learn how to shop for a doctor/healer
Demand that all clinical trials include women of varying ages from adolescent to older.
Teach women to negotiate condom use to avoid further infections of other STDs or HIV strains.
Provide information in all languages. Use networks; share info.
Require retraining for health care workers to deal with women & HIV
We need information about home remedies/practical solutions
Get together in local groups to share information and support each other
Use the Internet and e-mail to access and share information
Women must be encouraged to take responsibility for their own health
Empower women to be assertive in challenging their doctors. Caring for Ourselves and Others
In this workshop, women discussed their roles as care providers and the difficulties we often have caring for
ourselves. Many women expressed frustration and over not having the energy or support needed to care for
themselves and their children. Strategies for dealing with stress included meditation, relaxation, finding people to
talk to, exercise, engaging in meaningful work, and learning to love oneself.
Loss and Bereavement
Many positive women are dealing with multiple losses: not just the loss of a partner or child but also loss of
self-esteem, jobs, sex, friends, a future (watching children grow up) and inner self. A woman from England said
that every time someone dies she fears what will happen to her. A woman from the United States spoke of the
loss of innocence, For many there is anger mixed up in the grief. Children and HIV
Children often know a mother's status even before she discloses. They may be told by another family member or
may notice non-verbal clues. It is devastating for children to find out from others.
In many parts of the world, HIV+ children may go undiagnosed or misdiagnosed. Women worry that their
uninfected children may be denied health care or vaccines by providers who assume the child is positive (based
on the mother's status).
Children feel a tremendous emotional burden. Strategies for helping children deal with HIV included educating
people in the child's life about AIDS (including the child), counseling/therapy, and speaking honestly. Closing
Session
The closing session brought us back together again. Of course, two days wasn't nearly long enough. For many,
it was the first time they had seen another HIV+ woman, let alone room of 200. Until we see a cure for AIDS,
HIV+ women can bridge the isolation and support one another. As one woman said: "This has given me new
energy so I can keep on working when I'm back home."
The International Community of Women Living with HIV/AIDS
The ICW is the only international network run for and by HIV+ women. There are 15 Key Contacts worldwide
(elected at each pre-conference), a Coordinating Office in London, and an ICW liaison to the 1996 International
AIDS Conference Vancouver.
ICW Coordinating Office Joanne Manchester, Kate Thomson, Leigh Neal
2nd floor, Livingstone House, 11 Carteret St., London, SW1H 9DL U.K.
Tel:44-171-222-1333, Fax: 44-171-222-1242
1996 Vancouver Conference Liaison for the ICW
Cheryl Brown, POB 93655, Nelson Park P.O., Vancouver, BC, Canada, V6E 4G7 Asia/Pacific Siti Sarnah bte
Dhiffy
Apt. Blk 839, No. 05-304, Yishun St. 81 Singapore 2776 Tel: 65-752- 9700 Narumon Buayen
Thai-Australia Northern AIDS Prevention & Care Programme
14/10 Huay kaso Road Chiangmai 50330, Thailand
Tel: 61-8-362-1611, Fax: 61-8-363-1046 Vivienne Munro AIDS Council of New South Wales
PO Box 350, Darlinghurst, NSW 2010 Australia Tel: 61 2 206 2000, Fax: 61-2-206-2069
Caribbean Wendy Mejaries Community Action Resource (CARe)
101 Oxford St., Port of Spain, Trinidad Tel/Fax: 1-809-625-0632 North America
Yecenia DeJesus 245 Bennett Ave., #3B New York, NY 10040, U.S.A.
Tel: 212/926-4072, Fax: 212/296-2163 Cindy Robins POB 32593, 9665 Bayview Ave.
Richmond Hill, Ontario, L4C 0A2, Canada
Tel: 905/770-0699, Fax: 905/770-7874 Martina Clark 548-B Clayton St.,
San Francisco, CA 94117, U.S.A. Tel: 415/861-8799, Fax: 415/863-6425 email:martina@itsa.ucsf.edu
Latin America Lorena Loyola Droguett
Socrates 1924, Villa Raabco Malpu, Santiago, Chile Tel: 53-2-10923, Fax: 56-2-639-5040
Nair Soares De Brito E Britto Rua Santo Irineu, 285 Apto 64 Vila Mariana, Sao Paulo
Brazil, CEP 04127-120 Europe Claudia Fisher Deutsche AIDS Hilfe
Dieffenbachstr 33, 1000 Berlin 61 Germany
Tel: 49-30-6900-8739, Fax: 49-30-6900-8742 Rosemarie Rojas PG Syd, 5oderg 13 S-21134 Malme, Sweden
Tel: 46-40-79-161, Fax: 46-40-78-929 Elizabeth Da Paz SIDA Info Service
190 Bd De Charonne, 75020 Paris, France
Tel: 44-93-1655, Fax: 44-93-1600 Africa Jeanne Kouame Association Lumiere Action
64 BP 2113 Abidjan 04, Cote D'Ivoire Tel: 225-24-30-13, Fax: 225-24- 31-19
Beatrice Were PO Box 4485, Kampala, Uganda
Tel: 256-41-267-012/3, Fax: 256-41-62728 Winnie Chikafwmbwa NAPHAM, P/Bag 355
Capital City, Lilongwe 3, Malawi
Tel/Fax: 265-782-230
Clark, Martina, The urge to crawl inside my TV. , Contemporary Women's Issues Database, 05-01-1995, pp 1+.