A Justice Site
CSUDH - Habermas - UWP
California State University, Dominguez Hills
University of Wisconsin, Parkside
Soka University Japan - Transcend Art and Peace
Created: August 1, 2002
Latest Update: August 13, 2002
The Subjugated Elephant
Copyright: Jeanne Curran and Susan R. Takata and Individaul Authors, August 2002.
"Fair use" encouraged.
This teaching module is based on The Subjugated Elephant.
- Preparatory readings for module.
- Who speaks for the elephants and why?
Consider two levels here. How are the elephants going to tell their story to gain recognition for the pain they suffer? How is PETA going to gain enough political power to get the attention of the Arts Commission and transform the ideas of the circus-going public?
- Why isn't it enough that the elephants performance make the circus-going public aware of the elephants' plight?
Consdier Goffman's Presentation of Self, with a focus on the differenece between backstage and frontstage behavior.
- Does PETA want to subject circus-going children to the sight of the elephants' actual mistreatment? Why or why not?
Consider the description of the elephant PETA wants to exhibit. What connotes the suffering of the elephant? Consider also the fear studies in attitude change and persuasion theory. There were newspaper reports of the rejection of David Lynch's cow for the New York summer exhibit. Do you supppose his cow had a tear streaming down its cheek and shackles? Or do you suppose it offered a more frightening image?
Experiential activities related to module.
Self-test questions related to module.
True or False? And explain briefly why it's true or false. (25 words or less)
- Elephants are mistreated in circuses.
Conceptual linking we had in mind as we prepared the module.
- Attitude and persuasion studies on fear - social psychology.
- Good faith listening.
- Transformation of discourse through stories that seek recognition - Maria Pia Lara - Moral Textures.
- Transformation of discourse is seen in the ACLU's assistance to PETA in pressing its law suit in the name of the elephants.
- Stories of recognition must be told by the subjugated people themselves.