Link to What's New This Week Pet Lovers Howl, So Governor Rolls Over

Dear Habermas Logo and Link to Site Index A Justice Site

The Importance of Pets

Mirror Sites:
CSUDH - Habermas - UWP - Archives

California State University, Dominguez Hills
University of Wisconsin, Parkside
Soka University Japan - Transcend Art and Peace
Created: June 25, 2004
Latest Update: June 25, 2004

E-Mail Icon

Index of Topics on Site Backup of Pet Lovers Howl, So Governor Rolls Over
By Robert Salladay and Jason Felch, Times Staff Writers
SOURCE: Los Angeles Times
Copyright: Source Copyright.
Included here under Fair Use Doctrine for teaching purposes.

Casey, 4, who was rescued from the animal shelter
by Holly Williams and her family, was one of several
canines and their owners to demonstrate at the Capitol.

This backup copy is to be used only if the original site on the Web is not accessible. It is meant to preserve the document for teaching purposes, when sometimes the URLS are changed when sites are updated, or sites are eliminated. Please be certain to give credit if you use this to the original URL: Original URL,1,4067891.story Original Source URL.
Pet Lovers Howl, So Governor Rolls Over.

Pet Lovers Howl, So Governor Rolls Over
Schwarzenegger quickly drops a plan to save money by letting shelters euthanize strays in 72 hours. "That was an oversight," he says.
By Robert Salladay and Jason Felch
Times Staff Writers

June 26, 2004

SACRAMENTO — The hectoring barks of animal lovers convinced Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger to reverse himself Friday and keep California's law protecting stray dogs and cats at shelters.

"That's not me. I have three dogs. And of course I grew up with every animal you can think of," said Schwarzenegger, who credited his own daughter for persuading him to change his mind. "I'm an animal lover."

Schwarzenegger's about-face came a day after animal rights groups began besieging the Capitol upon learning that the governor wanted to cut back a six-day holding period for animals at shelters.

To save $14 million, the governor had proposed allowing dogs and cats to be euthanized within 72 hours.

Former state Sen. Tom Hayden, who wrote the law for dogs, cats, birds, rabbits, turtles, potbellied pigs and other creatures trapped at shelters, said if the governor is true to his word, he will call off the dogs.

"It shows that the governor has a disarming ability to confess a mistake and reverse course, which I find in few, if any, politicians," Hayden said.

"So, I'm going to put my barking dogs on their leashes and I'm going to counsel the owners of potbellied pigs to call off their intended assault."

The law requires shelters to hold animals for a minimum of six business days; four days if they stay open on weekends or one night a week. The act also forces people convicted of animal cruelty to pay for veterinary costs and remain pet-free for at least three years. And it requires animal shelters to look for adoptive homes instead of killing wayward pets with haste.

In an interview, Schwarzenegger described himself as a lover of animals who owns three dogs: Sarge, a cockapoo; and Sammy and Spunky, yellow labs.

He said the plan to repeal the six-day holding period was a mistake made when he hastily put together his original budget proposal after taking office last year. "That was an oversight of mine in December when we were trying to put the budget together in two seconds," he said.

Schwarzenegger likened the policy snafu to his aborted attempt last year to cut benefits for the developmentally disabled. He wound up reversing that plan, which would have saved $274 million over 18 months. Both moves, he said Friday, were borne of quickly assembling a $103-billion state budget.

"I came in here Nov. 17 and, all of a sudden, there I was the following week, sitting there, and I was bombarded with a lot of detailed information about the budget, and those two were oversights," he said.

"So there were certain mistakes like this that I made, including for the mentally disabled people. This was one of those things…. So animals will be kept in the shelters for six days and so everything will stay exactly the same. We are not going to take anything away from the shelters."

The governor's aides were talking to animal rights experts Friday afternoon. The groups want to make sure the entire law is retained, not just portions of it, so they are being cautious until the deal is sealed.

The issue over which government agency funds animal shelters has been a controversy since the Hayden Act was signed by former Gov. Pete Wilson in 1998. A state commission has ruled that the state owes local governments a total of $79 million for the costs of complying with the Hayden Act over the years, but the final figure remains in dispute.

Schwarzenegger's plan would have allowed shelters to euthanize dogs and cats within 72 hours, regardless of whether the facility was open to the public during those three days. Shelters would have been allowed to kill any other captured animals immediately, an idea that enraged potbellied pig owners, among others.

Despite the governor's reversal, tens of thousands of pets will continue to be euthanized at shelters throughout the state every month.

Los Angeles, for example, puts to death about 34,000 animals a year. They are among the 600,000 pets estimated to die annually in California shelters because owners cannot be found or the animals are vicious or sick.

Jennifer Fearing of United Animal Nations, which organized a protest against Schwarzenegger on Friday, said she was impressed that the governor confessed his mistake so quickly. She said she was optimistic that the Legislature would remove the governor's proposal from the state budget plan before it was passed. "I've very relieved and very thankful," Fearing said. "This felt like a mistake all along, but we had to assume otherwise because we didn't have anything to go on." Throughout the state on Friday, Schwarzenegger's plan had unleashed animal lovers. They said they were like pit bulls on the pant leg of the "pet terminator." His plan, they said, would have caused thousands of dogs and cats to be unnecessarily killed at shelters. On a lush Capitol lawn that looked like dog heaven, a King Charles spaniel barked Friday as a photographer snapped away at a sign around its neck: "Don't Kill Me, Arnold." Casey the spaniel and about a dozen other dogs were brought to the Capitol lawn for a "poop-in" demonstration, as a Sacramento talk radio host dubbed it, to protest the governor's plan. At the Capitol, the governor's Finance Department spokesman spent all day answering calls about animal rights instead of budget talks. A key state budget negotiator brought in extra staff members to answer the phones at his office. Talk radio shows went more loopy than usual as media outlets from Scotland to South Africa ran headlines that a mediagenic governor like Schwarzenegger surely wouldn't want to see. "Strays not safe around Arnold," said News24 in Cape Town, South Africa. Los Angeles Mayor James K. Hahn issued an order to the city's animal services director to continue to comply with the Hayden Act no matter what action the governor and Legislature might take. "The city of Los Angeles must continue to do everything possible to ensure that all adoptable shelter animals are found proper homes," Hahn's order said. Despite the victory Friday, some groups were sober about Schwarzenegger's reversal. Rich McLellan, director of the Animal Legislative Action Network in Los Angeles, said: "It's a victory when we make progress, not defend something we had already achieved." But others were joyful. Pamelyn Ferdin of the Animal Defense League of Los Angeles said Schwarzenegger "realized that there are millions of people that care about living, sentient beings. 'The Terminator' learned today that you can't cut the budget when it comes to killing innocent beings." Times staff writer Peter Nicholas contributed to this report.

Site Copyright: Jeanne Curran and Susan R. Takata and Individual Authors, June 2004.
"Fair use" encouraged.